Informations rapides
24 November 2020
2020- n° 293
The business climate in wholesale trade has deteriorated in November 2020 Bi-monthly survey of wholesaling - November 2020

According to the managers surveyed in November 2020, the business climate in wholesale trade has deteriorated a little between September and November. The composite indicator has lost 3 points and stands at 87, well below its long-term average (100). From May to September the business climate had only caught up with half of its fall related to the first lockdown. Between September and November, the balances of opinion related to ordering intentions and to the general business outlook have driven down the business climate.

Informations rapides
No 293
Paru le :Paru le24/11/2020
Prochaine parution le : 19/09/2025 at 08:45 - September 2025
Warning

Companies’ responses were collected from 28 October to 19 November, only through Internet given the ongoing lockdown. Furthermore, the survey sample has been partially renewed for the November 2020 survey. The response rate is therefore somewhat lower than usual.

According to the managers surveyed in November 2020, the business climate in wholesale trade has deteriorated a little between September and November. The composite indicator has lost 3 points and stands at 87, well below its long-term average (100). From May to September the business climate had only caught up with half of its fall related to the first lockdown. Between September and November, the balances of opinion related to ordering intentions and to the general business outlook have driven down the business climate.

Composite indicator

Composite indicator
Composite indicator
2005-B1 100.5
2005-B2 97.3
2005-B3 92.2
2005-B4 95.8
2005-B5 94.6
2005-B6 99.5
2006-B1 103.7
2006-B2 98.9
2006-B3 102.0
2006-B4 107.4
2006-B5 106.8
2006-B6 110.3
2007-B1 107.9
2007-B2 111.7
2007-B3 110.4
2007-B4 107.3
2007-B5 111.6
2007-B6 108.6
2008-B1 107.2
2008-B2 106.7
2008-B3 101.6
2008-B4 96.6
2008-B5 94.3
2008-B6 83.8
2009-B1 78.9
2009-B2 66.7
2009-B3 68.0
2009-B4 70.0
2009-B5 75.9
2009-B6 77.2
2010-B1 84.5
2010-B2 84.7
2010-B3 94.5
2010-B4 100.4
2010-B5 104.8
2010-B6 104.3
2011-B1 105.8
2011-B2 108.3
2011-B3 107.2
2011-B4 105.7
2011-B5 100.0
2011-B6 95.8
2012-B1 95.1
2012-B2 99.1
2012-B3 92.8
2012-B4 94.6
2012-B5 90.6
2012-B6 88.8
2013-B1 88.5
2013-B2 88.0
2013-B3 87.7
2013-B4 87.1
2013-B5 96.7
2013-B6 97.4
2014-B1 96.7
2014-B2 97.8
2014-B3 97.6
2014-B4 96.1
2014-B5 90.9
2014-B6 95.2
2015-B1 95.4
2015-B2 96.0
2015-B3 100.7
2015-B4 101.9
2015-B5 99.2
2015-B6 101.2
2016-B1 101.8
2016-B2 99.3
2016-B3 101.8
2016-B4 102.9
2016-B5 97.4
2016-B6 97.6
2017-B1 103.7
2017-B2 102.8
2017-B3 104.2
2017-B4 109.6
2017-B5 108.5
2017-B6 110.5
2018-B1 106.8
2018-B2 109.2
2018-B3 104.0
2018-B4 102.2
2018-B5 103.4
2018-B6 103.2
2019-B1 99.4
2019-B2 105.3
2019-B3 107.1
2019-B4 105.9
2019-B5 106.0
2019-B6 105.9
2020-B1 103.5
2020-B2 96.7
2020-B3 66.5
2020-B4 79.1
2020-B5 89.6
2020-B6 86.6

Composite indicator

  • Source: INSEE - business tendency survey in wholesale trade.

The balances of opinion regarding future activity have withdrawn sharply but not as much as in May 2020

The balance of opinion on the general business outlook in wholesale trade has sunk to −66, almost as low as in May 2020 (−72). Nevertheless, companies seem to be more pessimistic regarding the sector’s outlook than regarding their own situation. Indeed, although more wholesalers than in September have declared their ordering intentions to be lower than usually for this time of the year, the related balance of opinion has remained far above its May level.

The balance of opinion on ordering intentions for the next two months has diminished in all sub-sectors and remains everywhere well below its average level. It has shed 13 points in the wholesale trades of raw agricultural products and of information and communication equipment. The balance has lost 9 to 10 points in the wholesale trades of food products and beverages, of domestic goods and of other industrial capital goods. The drop is sharp (−7 points) but of a lesser extent in the other specialised wholesale trade (intermediate products, fuel, chemicals and the like).

Wholesalers expect the foreign demand to remain dull over the next two months since the balance of opinion related to shipments abroad has been stable, at a level well below its mean, after having fallen in September. As for the balance regarding ordering intentions from abroad, it has stepped back further away from its mean, signalling that the French wholesalers’ demand has decreased.

The balances of opinion related to past activity have hardly risen

From September to November 2020, the balances of opinion related to the activity of the past two months – sales and received merchandise – have hardly risen, after having recovered strongly from July to September. But the cumulated hikes since May have not offset the severe drop recorded between January and May.

The balance of opinion related to future workforce has plummeted

The balance of opinion regarding forecasted workforce size has receded to a level almost as low as in May. The balance regarding the recent change in workforce size has grown again, but much more slightly than in September.

The balances of opinion on selling prices have fallen nearly as much as in May

In November, the balances of opinion regarding past and expected selling prices have fallen back noticeably and have lost 6 points each. They had decreased by 7 points in May. Both were already well below their long-term average in September.

Hardly more wholesalers have considered their cash flow situation to be difficult in November than in September. The related balance has lost one point and has reached its average.

Updates

The business climate indicator in wholesale trade of September 2020 has been updated from 92 to 90 as a result of the integration of belated business answers.

Wholesale trade sectors

Balances of opinion in %, S.A.
Wholesale trade sectors (Balances of opinion in %, S.A.)
Ave* May-20 July-20 Sept.-20 Nov.-20
Composite indicators 100 67 79 90 87
General business outlook -23 -72 -41 -34 -66
Sales -14 -50 -42 -24 -21
export sales -16 -50 -39 -29 -30
Received merchandise -9 -48 -39 -23 -22
received from abroad -10 -45 -39 -23 -21
Ordering intentions -15 -50 -25 -25 -34
ordering from abroad -15 -49 -26 -27 -33
Shipments abroad -15 -49 -29 -37 -37
Stocks 8 9 5 1 2
Past workforce -1 -32 -25 -11 -8
Expected workforce -2 -20 -7 -3 -16
Cash position -9 -35 -17 -8 -9
Past selling prices 7 -4 2 1 -5
Expected selling prices 14 -1 1 1 -6
  • * : average since september 1979
  • Source : INSEE - business tendency survey in wholesale trade

Wholesale trade sectors

Balances of opinion, in %, S.A.
Wholesale trade sectors (Balances of opinion, in %, S.A.)
Ave* May-20 July-20 Sept.-20 Nov.-20
Raw agricultural products and live animals
Sales -13 -3 -27 -24 -22
Export sales -16 -12 7 -5 -20
Merchandise received from abroad -10 -6 -7 7 8
Ordering intentions -13 -25 -20 -23 -36
Current stock 5 -4 10 -4 0
Food products and beverages
Sales -14 -30 -38 -15 -31
Export sales -12 -40 -32 -17 -35
Merchandise received from abroad -13 -36 -32 -19 -23
Ordering intentions -11 -38 -33 -21 -31
Current stocks 5 -7 -5 -4 -1
Household goods
Sales -10 -59 -44 -27 -12
Export sales -11 -57 -38 -31 -30
Merchandise received from abroad -6 -46 -40 -24 -12
Ordering intentions -14 -46 -23 -22 -31
Current stock 12 20 18 14 20
Information and communication equipment
Sales -8 -56 -57 12 11
Export sales -13 -39 -69 22 26
Merchandise received from abroad -7 -48 -64 24 20
Ordering intentions -10 -44 -11 -13 -26
Current stock 8 16 0 12 -4
Other industrial capital goods
Sales -16 -84 -56 -28 -31
Export sales -21 -77 -57 -27 -35
Merchandise received from abroad -11 -72 -59 -23 -32
Ordering intentions -21 -76 -32 -35 -44
Current stock 12 27 8 7 -1
Other specialised wholesale trade
Sales -17 -63 -38 -36 -23
Export sales -19 -61 -47 -59 -43
Merchandise received from abroad -13 -57 -41 -49 -42
Ordering intentions -18 -64 -23 -28 -35
Current stock 6 2 -4 -12 -9
  • * : average since september 1979
  • Source : INSEE – business tendency survey in wholesale trade

Past activity (sales) in capital goods

Past activity (sales) in capital goods
Capital goods in information and communication Other industrial capital goods
2008-B1 -23.7 5.2
2008-B2 -5.5 4.4
2008-B3 2.8 -3.5
2008-B4 -7.0 -14.3
2008-B5 -10.8 -20.7
2008-B6 -15.4 -35.4
2009-B1 -32.7 -57.0
2009-B2 -60.4 -74.2
2009-B3 -63.9 -67.8
2009-B4 -63.0 -70.0
2009-B5 -56.5 -70.0
2009-B6 -20.5 -68.2
2010-B1 -13.5 -56.7
2010-B2 -36.0 -57.5
2010-B3 -0.5 -40.3
2010-B4 29.5 -32.9
2010-B5 19.8 -16.0
2010-B6 19.9 -18.1
2011-B1 14.6 -17.4
2011-B2 -11.2 1.8
2011-B3 0.4 6.7
2011-B4 -1.6 -0.3
2011-B5 -6.6 0.1
2011-B6 -27.6 -12.8
2012-B1 -12.2 -12.2
2012-B2 -15.9 -15.4
2012-B3 -24.1 -28.8
2012-B4 -22.6 -30.0
2012-B5 -16.2 -28.0
2012-B6 -29.9 -36.8
2013-B1 -37.1 -41.7
2013-B2 -12.4 -33.6
2013-B3 -18.5 -37.8
2013-B4 -39.0 -38.3
2013-B5 -16.7 -30.6
2013-B6 -11.6 -25.7
2014-B1 -28.3 -28.0
2014-B2 -14.4 -19.9
2014-B3 -15.1 -27.2
2014-B4 -9.7 -38.8
2014-B5 -24.0 -40.9
2014-B6 -9.3 -38.5
2015-B1 -12.5 -35.9
2015-B2 -7.5 -32.9
2015-B3 3.3 -28.6
2015-B4 -3.8 -22.4
2015-B5 -3.3 -24.6
2015-B6 -7.9 -27.8
2016-B1 0.5 -18.4
2016-B2 0.1 -21.4
2016-B3 -11.1 -17.4
2016-B4 -0.8 -17.0
2016-B5 -3.6 -24.5
2016-B6 -11.6 -19.2
2017-B1 -8.3 -16.2
2017-B2 -6.0 -12.2
2017-B3 -7.3 -6.8
2017-B4 -0.6 0.5
2017-B5 -1.3 -1.7
2017-B6 -7.0 8.9
2018-B1 -13.0 8.0
2018-B2 1.1 1.6
2018-B3 0.9 -5.0
2018-B4 7.5 -7.8
2018-B5 13.4 -6.7
2018-B6 5.8 -9.4
2019-B1 -21.4 -16.3
2019-B2 20.0 -3.2
2019-B3 10.4 -1.0
2019-B4 -20.8 -4.2
2019-B5 0.4 1.1
2019-B6 -5.2 -4.8
2020-B1 -19.1 -10.3
2020-B2 -4.8 -13.8
2020-B3 -56.2 -84.3
2020-B4 -57.2 -56.1
2020-B5 12.1 -28.1
2020-B6 11.4 -31.1

Past activity (sales) in capital goods

  • Source: INSEE - business tendency survey in wholesale trade

For further information

A balance of opinion is the difference between the weighted percentage of « above normal » or « increase » answers and the weighted percentage of « below normal » or « decrease » answers.

Since the May 2020 survey, the way of correcting missing answers has been modified. The usual method was to fill them in by carrying on past answers from non-responding companies. Results are now computed on the sole basis of responding companies.

Additional information (methodology, links, etc.) is available on the “Documentation” tab.

Next issue: 21 January 2020 at 8:45 am.

Pour en savoir plus

A balance of opinion is the difference between the weighted percentage of « above normal » or « increase » answers and the weighted percentage of « below normal » or « decrease » answers.

Since the May 2020 survey, the way of correcting missing answers has been modified. The usual method was to fill them in by carrying on past answers from non-responding companies. Results are now computed on the sole basis of responding companies.

Additional information (methodology, links, etc.) is available on the “Documentation” tab.

Next issue: 21 January 2020 at 8:45 am.

: bureau-de-presse@insee.fr